Document Type : Research Paper
Author
Associate Professor, Department of Law, Faculty of Humanities, Bu-Ali Sina University, Hamadan
Abstract
The criminal procedural may be exposed to the state of collapse by security-oriented policies resulting in suspense of the usual formalities of criminal proceedings and replacing them with emergency-oriented mechanisms. The collapse is due to the emergency of the country's political situation and social chaos, which is caused by the protests of a number of citizens against some policies. One of the most important factors of inception of such movement is the expansion of criminal law and maximum interference in people's freedoms and maintenance of political ideology. The Gap between the official norms and accepted values by citizens and insistence of the government to retain the norms via criminal protection of them gradually leads to social crises and civil disobedience. Conservatism, retrogression, standing against social and cultural changes, maintaining the status quo, refraining from fundamental reforms in political and social structures, have no result other than "crisis" and inevitably puts the citizens or a large part of them against the government. One simple solution to quell crisis is to declare the state of emergency and expand powers of the security forces and judicial authorities to arrest, prosecute and adjudicate the cases of protestors rapidly and secretly. The networks of control and supervision on citizens and the power and freedom of action of the police in this situation will be expanded and the logic of confrontation and repression are applied at high level. Due to the crowding of criminal cases in the judicial system as a result of these policies the rules of proceedings and some defense rights are ignored, including the right to have lawyer or the right to public trial, and prompt measures are taken into account due to the government's need to deal quickly and decisively. In such circumstances the guiding principles, especially the presumption and the principle of neutrality, and the government justifies its actions by claiming to maintain order and security of citizens. Summoning and arresting political dissidents without complying with legal frameworks and creating restrictions in cyberspace through filtering social networks and preventing the free flow of information are part of the strategies to deal with the crisis. When the political and social conditions are in an emergency, the fair criminal procedure inevitably collapses, and "extraordinary criminal procedure" prevails, which does not pay attention to the conventional and well-known rules of procedure and is often the product of the will of the political authorities and are dictated in the form of "judicial circulars". Thus, circulars have priority over the law. In this approach, the presumption of guilt is used instead of the principle of innocence, and the accused is treated as a criminal or a convict.
The collapse of fair procedures is caused by factors that are mainly related to public strategies and macro policies. Incorrect policies or making wrong decisions regarding some social events and phenomena, legislation without paying attention to the basic needs of the people and ignorance of the political dissidents inevitably aggregate protests and social uprisings. Criminal policies based on arbitrary and baseless criminalization and merely based upon defending and protecting ideology, expanding criminal laws and maximum interference in people's freedoms, as well as the lack of transparency in statutes have unpleasant consequences in long term, and provide confrontation between citizens and policy makers.
The substantive and procedural rules on security in the Iranian criminal law indicate that criminal policy makers have ignored some fundamental rights such as the right to choose a lawyer. In addition, following the expansion of the jurisdiction of special courts, which sometimes originates from circular, as well as the increase of the powers of judicial authorities and military forces, they have provided a legal basis for threatening the rights of individuals and the collapse of fair procedures. Holding secret and non-public trails and preventing the communication of court’s decisions are part of these challenges. Adjusting the criminalization and decriminalization of acts that are contrary to the values of citizens or a significant part of them, reforming public policies and avoiding criminal actions that create tension, and saving the criminal justice system from criminal inflation, and most importantly, paying attention to the phenomenon of "generational change" and normative gaps and ideology might be some solutions to prevent the collapse of fair criminal procedure. The Recognition of protests, changing policies and decriminalizing behaviors that have only an ideological aspect, removal of rights-threatening processes, accountability and prescribing discourse instead of criminal threats can prevent the criminal process from collapse.
Keywords
Main Subjects
- Afrasiabi, Ali, "The challenges of Adversarial Model in the judicial system of Italy and Iran", Quarterly of Legal Encyclopedias, 5th, 17, 2023.
- Aghaie Nia, Hossein; Rostami, Hadi, Criminal law, Crimes against Public Order, Third Ed, Tehran: Mizan publication, 2021.
- Albrecht, Hans-Jorg, Prison Overcrowding, Translated by Hossein Gholami, First Ed, Tehran: Mizan publication, 2016.
- Babakhani, Erfan; Rostami, Hadi, "Differential Investigation of Economic rimes in Iranian and French Law", Quarterly of Comparative Studies on Islamic and Western Law, 9th, 1, 2022.
- Castells, Manuel,"Network Society and New Identity", interview, The Journal of Majlis and Research, 11th, 43, 2004.
- Castells, Manuel, The Rise of the Network Society (The Power of Identity), The Second volume, Translated by Ahmad Aliqlian, Afshin Khakbaz and Hassan Chavoshian, Sixth Ed, Tehran: Tarhe No Publications, 2010.
- Delmas- Marty, Mireille, Large Systems of Criminal Politics, Translated by Ali Hossein Najafi Abrandabadi, Fourth Ed, Tehran: Mizan publications, 2019.
- Fathi , Mohammad Javad ; Dadyar, Hadi, "The Position of Prosecutor in Modern Criminal Policy and Fair Trial Requirements", The Journal of Fiqh and Islamic Jurisprudenc, Fourth Ed, 7, 2013.
- Gassin, Raymond, Criminology of Social Upheavals (about violent social upheavals in the sensitive suburbs of French cities, Translated by Shahram Ebrahimi, First Ed, Tehran: Mizan publication, 2020.
- Gassin, Raymond,"The Crisis of Criminal Policies in Western Countries", Translated by Ali Hossein Najafi Abrandabadi, Legal Research Quarterly, 10, 1992.
- Heywood, Andrew, Politics, Translated by Abdal-Rahman Alem, Twelfth Ed, Tehran: Ney publication, 2022.
- Heywood, Andrew, Political Theory: an Introduction, Translated by Abdal-Rahman Alem, fourth Ed, Tehran: Ghoomes publication, 2019.
- Lacche, Luigi, "The Shadow of the Law: The Special Court of Protection of the Government between Justice and Politics in the Fascist Period of Italy", in: Skinner, Stephen, Fascism and Criminal law, History, Theory, Continuity, Translated by Seyyed Basem Mavalizadeh, First Ed, Tehran: The SD Institute publication, 2020.
- Lazerges, Christine, Introduction to Criminal Policy, Translated by Ali Hossein Najafi Abrandabadi, 9nd Ed, Tehran: Mizan publications, 2021.
- Najafi Abrandabadi, Ali Hossein, "About Security Studies (From the Right to Security to the Right to Assurance)", preface in: Rezvani, Soodabeh, Human- Oriented Crime Risk Management, First Ed, Tehran: Mizan publication, 2012.
- Najafi Abrandabadi, Ali Hossein, "Conflict of Power- Security and Rights- Individual Liberties", in: Niazpour, A, Foundations, Challenges and Solutions, articles of the conference on the Criminal Procedure Code, Tehran: author's publication, 2016: Available at: http://lawtest.ir.
- Najafi Abrandabadi, Ali Hossein, "Delinquency, Feeling of Insecurity and Control (Investigation of the French Committee for Studies on Violence and Delinquency and its Recommendations in the Field of Criminal Policy", The Judiciary Law Journal, 62th, 22, 1998
- Najafi Abrandabadi, Ali Hossein, Lectures on Criminology (from Critical Criminology to Security Criminology), Faculty of Law, Shahid Beheshti University, prepared and edited by: Sakineh Khanalipour Vajargah and Mehdi Ghorbani, 2013, Available at: http://lawtest.ir.
- Najafi Abrandabadi, Ali Hossein, Lectures on Criminal Sociology, Master's course in Criminal Law and Criminology, Faculty of Law, Shahid Beheshti University, prepared and edited by: Mehdi Sabooripour, 2005, available at: http://lawtest.ir.
- Najafi Abrandabadi, Ali Hossein, "Legislator's Criminal Policy Discourse in Criminal Procedure Code 2013", in: Elfat, N, Pilgrimage of thought; Synergy of jurisprudence and law in the development of justice and human excellence, a collection of essays in the memoirs of the master martyr Dr. Haj Nasser Ghorban Nia, Second Ed, Qom: Mofid University Press,
- Najafi Abrandabadi, Ali Hossein; "Seeking Dignified Criminal Justice", Dialogue", a pecial issue of the Judiciary and Civil Rights Conference, 2007, available at: http://lawtest.ir.
- Najafi Abrandabadi, Ali Hossein, Criminal law, The Design of Criminal Policy in the Light of Public Policy Strategies, in: Mehra, N. and Niazpour, A, Penal Law in Movement, Essays on honor Professor M.A. Ardebili, First Ed, Tehran: Mizan publication, 2022.
- Nikoyee, Somayye, "Publicity Requirements of Criminal Proceedings in the Light of Fair Trial, The Judiciary Law Journal, 56-57, 2006.
- Picca, Georges, Criminology, Translated by Ali Hossein Najafi Abrandabadi, 6nd Ed, Tehran: Mizan publications, 2023.
- Razavifard, Behzad; Ghorbanzadeh, Hossein, "The Right to Public Proceeding as One of the Defensive Rights of the Accused in International Criminal Tribunals Procedure", Comparative Law ReviewQuarterly, 7th, 1, 2016.
- Rostami, Hadi, "Criminal Policy Based on Directives in Criminal Proceedings", Majlis and Strategy Quarterly, 28th, 108, 2021.
- Rostami, Hadi, Criminal Procedure, Third Ed, Tehran: Mizan publication,
- Sadr Touhid-Khaneh, Mohammad, "Laws in the Circle of "the Enemy", from the American Policy of "War on Terror" to the German Theory of "Criminal Rights of Enemies"", in: Najafi Abrandabadi, Ali Hossein, Essays on Criminal Sciences, First Ed, Tehran: Mizan publication, 2009.
- Saney, Parviz, Law and Society, First Ed, Tehran: Tarh-e No publications, 2003.
- Skinner, Stephen, Fascism and Criminal law, History, Theory, Continuity, Translated by Seyyed Basem Mavalizadeh, First Ed, Tehran: The SD Institute publication, 2020.
- Soltanfar, Gholamreza; Shambyati, Houshang ; Azmayesh, Ali, "The Influence of Ideologies on the Limitation and Expansion of the Scope of Criminal Law, Scientific Quarterly of International Legal Research, 10th, 37, 2016.
- Stanley, Jason, How Fascism Works: The Politics of Us and Them, Translated by Babak Takhti, First Ed, Tehran: Negah publication, 2019.
- Skinner, Stephen, "Introduction: Fascism and Criminal law; One of the most obvious features of governance", in: Skinner, Stephen, Fascism and Criminal law, History, Theory, Continuity, Translated by Seyyed Basem Mavalizadeh, First Ed, Tehran: The SD Institute publication, 2020.
- Taati, Mahakameh; Keshavarz Tork, Einollah; Ghasemi, Hakem; Darvishi Setallani, Farhad, Impact of Foresight on Policy Making and Anticipatory Governance with a Global Perspective, The Journal of Science and Technology Policy Letters (JSTPL), 11th, 34, 2021.
ب. انگلیسی
- Dubber, Markus (2004), “The Criminal Trial and the Legitimation of Punishment”, THE TRIAL ON TRIAL, R.A. Duff et al. eds., Available at: SSRN: https://ssrn.com.
- Husak, Douglas (2008), Over Criminalization, The Limits of the Criminal Law, Oxford University Press.
- HRC, Comments on Peru, U.N. Doc. CCPR/C/79/Add.67 (1996), July 25, 1996, Para. 25.
- McLachlin, Beverley (2014). Openness and the Rule of Law, London: At the Annual International Rule of Law Lecture.
)